archive: SETI Re: [acc-list] Argus, Sagan and Clarke

SETI Re: [acc-list] Argus, Sagan and Clarke

Larry Klaes ( lklaes@bbn.com )
Fri, 28 May 1999 09:38:57 -0400

>Date: Fri, 28 May 1999 09:38:03 -0300
>From: "John C. Sherwood" <sherwood@internet1.net>
>Reply-To: sherwood@internet1.net
>Organization: MysteryVisits.com
>X-Mailer: Mozilla 3.04 (Macintosh; I; PPC)
>To: Larry Klaes <lklaes@bbn.com>
>CC: carlsagan@craigerware.avalon.net, acc-list@clarke.lac.usp.br,
> Seth_M._Miller@glfn.org, n6tx@setileague.org
>Subject: Re: [acc-list] Argus, Sagan and Clarke
>
>"Dr. H. Paul Shuch" <n6tx@setileague.org> wrote:
>> When The SETI League announced our choice of names for our search, Carl
>>Sagan (who used "Project Argus" for his search in the novel 'Contact')
>>jokingly accused me of stealing the name from him. My response was, "No,
>>Carl; I stole it from the same place you did: Arthur Clarke's 'Imperial
>>Earth'."
>
>By the way, consider this plot sketch:
>
>"An extraterrestrial species of vast intellectual and technological
>superiority to human beings confronts Earthlings with a complex
>communications technology. This initial contact provokes a small band of
>humans to leave Earth to learn more about the ETs. The Earthlings
>encounter conflict and hardship because of their own foibles, but
>eventually one member of the human party is allowed to make contact with
>the ETs, in a place and time generated by the ETs to resemble an Earth
>environment. There, the ETs do not reveal their own form, but
>nonetheless impart to the sole human ambassador a revelation about the
>complexity of the universe and the surprising high relevance of the
>human species."
>
>Sound familiar? I imagine that "Argus" may have been just one of the
>things Dr. Sagan, despite his own genius, borrowed from Sir Arthur.
>
>--
>
>John C. Sherwood
>
>Opinion page editor, Battle Creek Enquirer, 155 W. Van Buren St., Battle
>Creek, MI 49017
> (616) 966-0688
>Artistic director emeritus, The Victorian Villa Inn, 601 N. Broadway,
>Union City, MI 49094
> (800) 34-VILLA for inquiries
>MysteryVisits.com, 120 W. Hanover St., Marshall, MI 49068
> (616) 781-5478 or (616) 781-9353
>E-mail: sherwood@internet1.net
>or jcsherwood@yahoo.com
>Web site: http://www.MysteryVisits.com
>